10 Best Air Fryer With Replacement Tray 2026 (Reviewed)

⚡ Quick Verdict

📋 How We Evaluated

Evaluation focused on build quality, including food-grade metal and coatings, and whether the parts fit advertised dimensions. Performance considerations included airflow design, crisping suitability, and heat-resistance guidance. Value and suitability also relied on expected lifespan, ease of cleaning, and available Amazon-style rating signals, even when ratings were missing.

Compatible Models	Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65, TOA-70
Baking Pan Size	12.4 x 11 inches
Basket Rack Size	11.5 x 10 x 2 inches
Heat Limit Guidance	480°F with 300°F preheat for 10 minutes

What We Found

This Cuisinart replacement tray aims at TOA-60, TOA-65, and TOA-70 convection toaster ovens. It lists a 12.4 x 11 inch baking pan, plus an 11.5 x 10 x 2 inch basket rack. The build is food-grade stainless steel, with BPA-free and non-toxic claims.

Preheating is emphasized again, recommending a 300°F warm-up for 10 minutes before regular cooking. The listing also highlights mesh design for 360° heat circulation. For cleanup, it suggests liners like foil or parchment when splatter builds up.

Who It’s For

This works for Cuisinart owners who want both a tray and rack replacement, not just one piece. I would pick it for batch cooking, like wings, fries, and vegetables, where splatters can stack quickly. Dishwasher-safe handling plus the preheat guidance makes it easier to maintain the setup properly.

Compatible Models	Ninja AF100/AF101/AF150/AF161 and compatible 8.2-inch units
Tray Size	8.2 x 8.2 inches
Coating	Enameled non-stick, double-layer spray claim
Cleaning	Dishwasher safe with non-abrasive care

What We Found

This Ninja replacement grill pan targets AF101 and AF161 Max XL models, plus AF150 XL units, and it also mentions an 8.2 x 8.2 inch crisper plate for certain Ninja Foodi accessories. The listing calls out BPA-free, non-toxic, and tasteless materials.

A handle design stands out, since it is meant to make removal easier during and after cooking. The surface uses an enameled, non-stick coating with a double-layer spray claim. Cleanup guidance highlights dishwasher safety and recommends avoiding abrasive handling to protect the coating.

The package includes a cleaning cloth and rubber bumpers, which can help stabilize the tray.

Who It’s For

I would shortlist this for Ninja owners who want a handle-equipped replacement for everyday crisping. It suits smaller meals, like fries, roasted vegetables, and grilled-style items, where non-stick release is useful. The included bumpers appeal if you want steadier placement in the basket.

Just double-check the 8.2-inch square dimensions before ordering.

Compatible Models	Gourmia GAF858, GAF823 8 QT air fryers
Plate Size	9.6 x 9.6 inches
Material	Food-grade stainless steel
Cleaning	Dishwasher safe; non-abrasive care recommended

What We Found

This Gourmia replacement grill pan targets GAF858 and GAF823 8 QT air fryers, using a 9.6 x 9.6 inch square size. It is made from food-grade stainless steel, with FDA-oriented, BPA-free and non-toxic positioning.

The crisper plate includes a handle for easier removal, and it has a non-stick coating intended to help food release. A highlighted feature is whirlwind airflow, aimed at more even heating across steak, fish, vegetables, and fries.

Cleaning guidance states dishwasher safety, and it includes a magic cleaning cloth and rubber bumpers. The listing also advises against rough abrasives and suggests measuring your basket dimensions before ordering.

Who It’s For

I would shortlist this for Gourmia 8 QT owners who want a sturdy replacement when the grid degrades or coatings wear. It fits people who cook mixed menus and want more even heat distribution. Dishwasher-friendly care helps if you run frequent cooking cycles.

Because it is a square format, it can be a good match for batches that need more surface area. Just measure carefully, since fit is key to the airflow concept.

Compatible Models	Ninja AF100 to AF161; select Foodi models
Plate Size	8.2 x 8.2 inches
Coating	Ceramic-coated non-stick
Surface Feature	Perforated for crisping

What We Found

This Ninja replacement crisper plate targets AF100 through AF161 air fryers, plus several Foodi models, using an 8.2 x 8.2 inch size. It uses food-grade material with a ceramic-coated, non-stick surface meant for easier food release.

The handle helps lift the plate out of the basket, which matters when you cook frequently. The perforated design is meant to encourage airflow for crispier crusts. Cleaning guidance says dishwasher-safe, and it advises against rough abrasives that could damage the coating.

The listing highlights foods like fries, onion rings, pizza, chicken, steak, and fried vegetables for a wide range of crisping tasks.

Who It’s For

This is a good fit for Ninja owners who want a ceramic-coated surface and simple cleanup. I would choose it if you cook crisp foods regularly and want dishwasher-friendly maintenance. The perforations make sense for items that benefit from airflow, like fries and onion rings.

It is also a solid choice when the 8.2-inch square footprint matches your basket system.

Compatible Model	Power XL 5QT air fryer
Plate Size	8.74 x 8.74 inches
Coating	Enameled non-stick with double-layer spray claim
Cleaning	Dishwasher safe with non-abrasive care

What We Found

This Power XL replacement grill plate is for the 5QT round system, and it lists dimensions of 8.74 x 8.74 inches. It uses food-grade stainless steel with an enameled, non-stick coating, plus a double-layer spraying claim. The plate includes a handle to help lift it from the basket during cooking.

Cleaning guidance says dishwasher safety, and it again advises avoiding rough abrasives to protect the coating. The biggest limitation is model fit, since it specifically calls out Power XL 5QT compatibility and warns against other models.

The kit includes a magic cleaning cloth and rubber bumpers to improve stability while cooking.

Who It’s For

I would choose this if you own a Power XL 5QT and want the closest matching replacement for a worn or missing crisper plate. It suits cooks who make quick batches like fries, chicken sides, and vegetables, where non-stick release helps.

If you want dishwasher-friendly maintenance, this aligns well with that routine. It is best for buyers who will confirm size and compatibility first.

Compatible Models	Gourmia GAF798, GAF716
Plate Size	22.6 x 22.6 x 1.9 cm (8.9 x 8.9 x 0.75 inches)
Material	Carbon steel
Airflow Feature	Cyclonic airflow design

What We Found

This Gourmia replacement grill plate fits GAF798 and GAF716 air fryer models. It includes one square plate, listed at about 22.6 x 22.6 x 1.9 cm, or 8.9 x 8.9 x 0.75 inches. The listing uses carbon steel and claims sturdy construction that resists breaking or deforming.

It highlights cyclonic airflow for more even heating and flavor development across steak, fish, fries, pizza, barbecue, chicken wings, and vegetables. For care, it recommends cleaning with a soft sponge or cloth, which suggests you may not want heavy-duty dishwasher cycles for long-term coating protection.

The listing also states it is not sponsored, endorsed, or affiliated with Gourmia, indicating a third-party replacement. The main strength is the straightforward material-focused design, while the weak point is limited detail on coating type and official heat limits.

Who It’s For

I would shortlist this for Gourmia owners who want a carbon-steel replacement for the GAF798 or GAF716 systems. It suits people who cook a mix of foods and care about even heating and consistent browning. If you prefer manual cleaning with softer tools, it fits that routine.

Buyers should confirm the exact size since the listing focuses heavily on model compatibility and includes a single plate only.

Compatible Models	Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65, TOA-70
Tray Size	12.48 x 10.94 x 0.7 inches
Max Heat Resistance	480°F
Material	Food-grade steel

What We Found

This Cuisinart replacement basket tray targets TOA-60, TOA-65, and TOA-70 toaster ovens, with a 12.48 x 10.94 x 0.7 inch profile. It uses food-grade steel, with BPA-free and non-toxic positioning. The listing stresses preheating before first use, recommending a 300°F bake for 10 minutes to help prevent warping.

For cooking, it calls out wings, fries, vegetables, and basic baking-style tasks. Cleaning guidance highlights dishwasher-friendly use and suggests avoiding rough abrasives to protect the surface.

Who It’s For

I would shortlist this if you need a direct replacement for compatible Cuisinart TOA models. It fits home cooks focused on quicker turnaround, when a bent or worn basket surface affects airflow. If you are willing to follow the preheat step, it should help restore everyday crisping and cleanup.

Compatible Units	Ninja Foodi SP101, SP201, SP301 Digital air fryer countertop oven
Includes	Crumb tray pan plus 4 black Teflon cleaning pads
Max Temperature Guidance	480°F
Material Claims	PTFE; BPA-free and PFOA-free

What We Found

This product is not a tray replacement, it is a crumb tray liner system for compatible Ninja Foodi SP101, SP201, and SP301 Digital air fryer countertop ovens. The package includes a non-stick baking-sheet style liner plus four black Teflon cleaning pads.

The listing warns that Teflon should not exceed 480°F, and it recommends reusing liners below 450°F. The liners are positioned as a way to reduce messy cleanup by catching crumbs and splatter. It also lists PTFE and claims BPA-free and PFOA-free.

The performance benefit is mostly about maintenance convenience, since the liner sits between crumbs and the unit’s tray.

Who It’s For

I would use this for Ninja Foodi owners who hate crumb buildup and want faster cleanup after cooking. It works best when you make crumb-heavy foods, like breaded items, seasoned wings, and snack-style batches. If your cooking stays in moderate heat ranges, the temperature limits make more sense.

It also suits buyers who prefer removable, reusable accessories.

What to Look For Before Buying

Choosing the best air fryer with a replacement tray starts with compatibility. I would match your air fryer model number, then verify tray length, width, and height. After that, I look for food-grade materials, the coating details, and any heat-limit guidance that fits your cooking style.

Finally, I prioritize cleaning convenience, since a replacement only helps if maintenance is easier.

Check Verify exact tray dimensions and model compatibility

Replacement trays only work well when they actually fit your basket. Compare your current tray measurements to the listing, including thickness and any handle clearance. Also check model notes like TOA-60 versus TOA-70 or AF101 versus AF161, since airflow can change with gaps.

If the listing says to measure before ordering, treat it like a must-do step.

Value Balance build material, coating, and included accessories

I would balance build material, coating, and what comes in the box. Food-grade stainless steel and carbon steel tend to hold shape through repeated heating. Non-stick or ceramic coatings can make release easier, but they vary with heat cycles and how you clean them.

Bundles that include rubber bumpers, cleaning cloths, or a tray plus rack can be more useful day to day.

Rating Use rating signals even when product listings look similar

When ratings exist, I trust patterns in reviews more than a single standout comment. Look for repeated notes about warping, coating peeling, or sizing mismatches. If rating data is missing, I compensate by checking material specs and any stated heat limits.

Clear compatibility statements and easy return policies also lower the risk.

Verify Follow preheating and care instructions to protect the replacement

Some replacements need preheating before first use, especially certain steel or coated trays. Follow the listed temperature and time, then let everything cool before handling. Avoid rough abrasives and metal tools that can break down non-stick surfaces. If residue builds up, use the gentler cleaning approach the listing recommends.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are replacement trays interchangeable across different air fryer brands?

Not usually. Basket geometry and airflow paths vary by brand and model, so most trays are not interchangeable. Compatibility listings typically name model families and specific dimensions. I would measure your current tray, then match the listing size and thickness.

Do replacement trays really need preheating before first use?

Sometimes, yes. Some steel and coated trays include preheating instructions to reduce the risk of warping. If the listing recommends a temperature and time, following it can help protect the surface. Skipping it may shorten the lifespan, especially for thinner or specially formed parts.

Which material choice performs best for durability?

Stainless steel and carbon steel often handle durability better under repeated heating. Non-stick or ceramic coatings can help with release, but coating longevity depends on heat exposure and how you clean. For maximum durability, I would prioritize sturdy metal construction and non-abrasive care.

Can replacement trays go in the dishwasher?

Many are marketed as dishwasher-safe, but loading and scrubbing still affect wear. If you use a dishwasher, I would choose gentler cycles and avoid abrasive scrubbers. When a listing suggests soft sponge cleaning, manual care usually protects coatings longer.

Do crumb tray liners improve cooking quality?

Crumb tray liners mainly help with cleanup, not crisping. They catch crumbs and splatter so residue buildup is easier to manage. Cooking results still depend mostly on the fryer tray, basket rack, and airflow design. If you hate post-cook mess, liners can be worth it.

🎯 Final Verdict

My top pick is the Cuisinart TOA-60/TOA-65/TOA-70 replacement tray set, because the stainless-steel build and 360° mesh airflow focus match the job, restore the setup, and keep cleanup manageable.

If you want an alternative, I would consider the Ninja 8.2-inch grill pan, since the handle design and included rubber bumpers make transfers feel easier. Confirm your model and tray measurements first, then choose based on whether you need a full tray-rack replacement or just a single crisper plate.